Uncategorized

Why Elon Musk thinks ‘impoundment’ could be the key to making his DOGE ideas a reality

Donald Trump and “first buddy” Elon Musk aren’t even formally in power yet, but they already appear to be chafing at the spending constraints Congress could place on them.

So political and economic observers might be wise to familiarize themselves with the wonky concept of “impoundment,” which concerns what happens when Congressionally appropriated money simply isn’t spent by the president’s executive branch.

This bit of Washington-ese is important, as it could be determinative about whether Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy and their new extra-governmental “Department of Government Efficiency” can follow through on some of their bigger ideas, such as cutting the annual federal budget by at least $2 trillion.

Elon Musk and President-elect Donald Trump talk as he arrives to attend a viewing of the launch of the sixth test flight of the SpaceX Starship rocket on Nov. 19 in Brownsville, Texas. (Brandon Bell/Getty Images) · Brandon Bell via Getty Images

Musk and Ramaswamy are looking to cut a lot but lack any formal authority to do so; it’s Congress that has the “power of the purse” to decide how governmental money is used.

But the incoming Trump team may aim to at least tweak that.

Just this week, in a Wall Street Journal op-ed focused on a range of strategies the two men are looking to employ, Musk and Ramaswamy noted the importance of impoundment to their plans and said the question may end up before the Supreme Court.

They argued that the current presidential limits are unconstitutional, saying Trump will challenge them “and we believe the current Supreme Court would likely side with him on this question.”

Trump has also weighed in on the issue in a campaign video in the summer of 2023, when he said that the law “wrongfully curtailed” the president’s powers in this area and called it “a blatant violation of the separation of powers.”

A Watergate-era reform following abuses by Richard Nixon

Whether justices indeed agree with Trump and Musk remains to be seen.

But what will be at issue if a case reaches their docket is a Watergate-era reform called the Impoundment Control Act of 1974.

The law laid out a process that the president must follow if he or she wishes to diverge from congressionally mandated funding for any program.

In short: The White House needs to go back to Congress to ask permission.

Impoundment was indeed a power that presidents enjoyed for most of US history, but it was traditionally used only to send back excess funds if Congress put aside too much.

That changed when then-President Richard Nixon attempted to stymie an environmental project using the impoundment process after Congress overrode his veto and allocated the money against his wishes.

Then-president Richard Nixon during the final night of the 1972 Republican National Convention in Miami. (Fair𝘤𝘩𝘪𝘭𝘥 Archive/WWD/Penske Media via Getty Images) · WWD via Getty Images

That action led to the 1974 law (part of a wave of post-Watergate reforms) and was further solidified by a Supreme Court ruling in 1975 that has been interpreted as saying the president can’t use impoundment to frustrate the will of Congress.

Trump has also toyed with impoundment authority before, most notably when he slow-walked funds to Ukraine as he pressured that country’s president, Volodymyr Zelensky, to help him politically by pushing for an investigation into Joe Biden.

The move helped lead to Trump’s first impeachment, with the temporary withholding of those funds deemed illegal at the time by a government watchdog.

Congressional Democrats responded then with a pledge to push back, vowing “Congress will not bend to executive overreach.”

A separation of powers clash in the making

This time around, Trump, Musk, and Ramaswamy appear very much interested in going even further.

“With impoundment, we can simply choke off the money,” Trump offered in his 2023 video. Musk and Ramaswamy have added that they want to eliminate entire departments (“delete as many as possible,” Musk recently posted) which could run into deep resistance in Congress.

Former presidential candidate Vivek Ramaswamy speaks at a Trump campaign rally at Madison Square Garden on October 27 in New York City. (Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images) · Michael M. Santiago via Getty Images

In their recent communications, Musk and Ramaswamy have also laid out an array of alternate strategies to accomplish their goal in unorthodox ways. Their ideas range from overriding civil services protections to cut agencies to the “minimum number of employees required” to using a recent Supreme Court decision around federal regulations as a battering ram to more deeply cut red tape.

Musk and Ramaswamy have also floated cuts to annual federal expenditures where funding has technically lapsed, though experts have noted that the biggest-ticket item there is a politically popular one that provides veterans with healthcare.

Related Posts

ATSUSHIが一酸化炭素中毒で休業、自ら命を絶つ最期を選んだと噂される理由に一同驚愕…【EXILE 芸能】

人気グループEXILEのボーカル、ATSUSHIさんが体調不良を理由に活動休止を発表しました。所属事務所の発表によると、ATSUSHIさんは3月中旬に体調に不調を感じ、その後の検査で一酸化炭素中毒の疑いがあることが判明したとのことです。この知らせを受け、ファンや関係者の間では自殺未遂の噂も浮上していますが、真相は異なるようです。   ATSUSHIさんは2001年にEXILEのメンバーとしてデビュー以来、多くの名曲を世に送り出し、ソロ活動にも力を入れてきました。しかし、今年4月の活動休止発表により、予定されていた公演は延期または中止となりました。事務所は、体調不良の原因が一酸化炭素である可能性があると説明しています。   一酸化炭素は無色無臭で非常に危険な物質であり、吸い込むことで急激に症状が現れることがあります。特に屋内での事故が多く、過去5年間で40人以上が救急搬送されています。ATSUSHIさんの体調不良は、仕事関係者との会食後に発生した疑いがあり、その際の換気不足が影響した可能性が高いと考えられています。   医師によると、一酸化炭素中毒の症状は数日から数週間後に現れることがあり、これを揮発性脳症と呼びます。ATSUSHIさんも現在、治療に専念しており、徐々に回復に向かっているとのことです。事務所は、ライブパフォーマンスができるまでには至っていないが、治療の必要があると判断したとしています。   ファンは彼の復帰を待ち望んでいますが、まずは健康を最優先にしてほしいと願っています。ATSUSHIさんの美しい歌声が再び響く日を心待ちにしています。  

Twin Pilots Share First Flight Together and Surprise Their Father on Father’s Day

United Airlines pilots Jamil and Jalal Paul, twin brothers, made this Father’s Day unforgettable by flying together for the first time in their careers and surprising their father…

Elon Musk’s estranged daughter, Vivian, annihilates father in 90-minute rant, calls his once-leftist stance a ‘marketing scheme’

Elon Musk’s estranged transgender daughter, Vivian Wilson, annihilated her father in a 90-minute rant, exposing what she claims are his actual political views. During a recent YouTube interview with influencer Hasan…

Elderly Pennsylvania woman donates jacket with a winning $2.5M lottery ticket she left in the pocket

A woman in Pennsylvania lost a winning $2.5 million lottery ticket after leaving it in a jacket she donated to charity. Mildred Simoneriluto, 76, is trying to track…

Tiger Woods sends golf world into meltdown with shock tweet claiming he will play at the Masters… three weeks after surgery

Tiger Woods has announced he is set to play at the Masters next week in a stunning post on social media – but fans quickly realized all is not…

Tiger Woods caddie he fired highlights difference of winning Masters with rival golfer

For years, Steve Williams carried Tiger Woods’ bag through some of the most dominant stretches in golf history, witnessing firsthand the relentless, almost robotic pursuit of victory that defined Woods’…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *