Uncategorized

Homeowner gets $1.8m payout in seven-year legal battle with HOA – it ‘refused to investigate’ issue destroying home

AN elderly couple has been awarded a massive $1.8 million payout after a seven-year legal feud with their homeowner’s association.

Homeowners Doug Ridley and Sherry Shen will be paid out the largest known lawsuit amount in California against their HOA for fraud and elder abuse.

Homeowners Doug Ridley and Sherry Shen are receiving a $1.8 million payout for their seven-year legal battle (stock image)Credit: Getty

The retirees found an abandoned well under their condo in Santa Clara, California (stock image)Credit: Getty

Last month, a judge ruled that the Rancho Palma Grande Homeowners Association in Santa Clara “engaged in extensive deception” over an abandoned well found under the couple’s condo.

The ruling comes after a long legal battle that began when Ridley and Shen, who have owned their three-bedroom home since 1991 and previously rented it out, found water puddling in their house’s crawlspace in April 2018.

Their HOA concluded the water was coming from an abandoned well more than 400 feet deep under their living room, according to court documents obtained by The Mercury News.

Ridley, 85, installed a sump pump under the house to fight the mold and awful smell that would “practically knock your head off” when the issue first started, but it was no use.

As the fungus grew worse, Ridley and Shen went to their HOA to beg for help – but they refused to look into the problem, insisting the home was still habitable.

Ridley and Shen were forced to dip into their retirement income to address their condo’s damages.

“I had to sell things I wouldn’t have dreamt of selling – stocks and stock options and whatever had to go to fund the work that we were doing,” Ridley told The Mercury News.

“The HOA would not investigate, so we paid to investigate.”

In September 2019, the retirees found the ground under the living room’s crawlspace had collapsed into a sinkhole.

But the collapse could’ve been preventable, according to Santa Clara County Superior Court Judge JoAnne McCracken.

McCracken said in her decision on February 26 that if the HOA “acted timely, the well could have been located and destroyed in a few months.”

Court documents showed the HOA had taken a few steps to address the issue by June 2018 but hadn’t acted with any urgency.

The HOA’s attorney, Steve Barber, claimed in a letter to the city and the water department in January 2019 that experts didn’t say there was a well under the house and instead blamed it on rain soaking into the ground.

Former HOA president Steve Moritz admitted in court he knew Barber’s letter was full of lies.

Moritz repeatedly told Ridley the condo was still livable despite the known mold issues.

In January 2020, the HOA finally explored the sinkhole and found it had “no discernible bottom,” court documents said.

The well was discovered and, a month later, destroyed.

The hole in the floor has since closed up, but Ridley and Shen’s home is still uninhabitable due to the ruined floors.

One of Ridley and Shen’s attorneys, Mary Ann O’Hara, said the couple deserves their $1.8 million award for the stress they’ve dealt with over the past seven years.

“It’s really put them through the ringer emotionally, financially,” O’Hara told The Mercury News.

“And it’s nothing that this hard-working couple should have to go through after working between the two of them over 100 years to deserve their retirement in peace and to have it disrupted in this way, they never would have chosen that.”

The HOA and Moritz are responsible for the million-dollar payout, which includes lost rent, damages, and emotional distress.

The HOA has 60 days after February 26 to appeal the court’s decision.

Related Posts

24-year-old Mother of 1 breaks 35 years record of Bayero University, bags first-class degree in Law

A 25-year-old mother of one named Aisha Widad Yahaya has broken a long-standing academic record at Bayero University, Kano (BUK), Nigeria, by graduating with first-class honors in Law….

Elon Musk’s DOGE is claiming victory after uncovering $382 million in unemployment fraud—but the government already found it years ago: ‘I don’t think it’s news to anyone’

The latest government waste touted by billionaire Elon Musk’s cost-cutting Department of Government Efficiency is hundreds of millions of dollars in fraudulent unemployment claims it purportedly uncovered. One…

Caroline Wozniacki’s Masters ‘winner’ comments resurface after ex Rory McIlroy’s major triumph

The fallout from Rory McIlroy’s thrilling 2025 Masters win continues. Days after the Northern Irishman completed a career Grand Slam at Augusta National, where he defeated England’s Justin Rose…

Erica Stoll’s reward for loyalty revealed: How Rory McIlroy is eyeing up huge change to satisfy loyal wife after divorce humiliation

There’s nothing like writing your name in the sporting history books to announce a new chapter in your life – and Rory McIlroy, after many frustrated years of trying,…

The poor janitor at the PGA golf course helped Nelly Korda fix a flat tire, and the next day, a white SUV appeared in front of his house!

In a heartwarming turn of events that has captivated the community, a humble janitor working at a prestigious PGA golf course received an unexpected gesture of gratitude from…

Rory McIlroy’s $2.5M mansion he had to give up and where he lives now with Erica Stoll

Rory McIlroy has made history after winning the Masters at Augusta to finally complete a career Grand Slam. The Northern Irishman had a nightmare start to the week but came…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *